| 11 Mar 2008 | John R Farley Jr | Loading...The hills kind of look like ice cream dips. But I’m sure that’s not what you intended. It’s kind of a strange (in a good way) picture in that it looks happy when you look at it, but it really isn’t a happy picture. Sort of unsettling, but good. Because it’s not what I expected. Anne Wipf replies: "For the ice cream dips, someone else already noticed it. It was not my intention, of course, but I’m not worry with the comparing: it is not really a sad picture, the gift of Galadriel gives a great hope. Nevertheless, the sky is grey and the earth brown, as if it was a long winter. Thank you for your kind comment." | |
| 11 Mar 2008 | Dave Cripps | Loading...Maybe I missed something but what kind of seeds would those trees have. Nuts, sycamore style helicopters or as you have here little seeds with fluff like dandelion seeds? LOL those stylised fields do look like ice cream scoops. I like the mint choc chip ones  Anne Wipf replies: "A bit of all kind of seed... Thank you for your kind comment. But, for the ice cream scoops, I like better pistachio and coffee... LOL Thank you for your kind comment " | |
| 13 Mar 2008 | Barbara J. Wickham | Loading...This has a great sense of hope and optimism. Even though the land is devestated, you have painted it in a way that is very nice to look at and promises that things will get better. Anne Wipf replies: "Thank you " | |
| 18 Mar 2008 | Richard Svensson | Loading...You should really be given the opportunity to fully illustrate a Tolkien story (The Hobbit would be a perfect choise). Anne Wipf replies: "Thank you, Richard. But it is not so easy to convince some publishers " | |
| 11 Feb 2009 | Heidi Hecht | Loading...Neato...I think this is the first picture I’ve seen of Sam’s gift. Which I think was as important as all the others, since it meant he could begin the work of undoing all the damage that Mordor did. You did an awesome job with watercolors. Anne Wipf replies: "Yes, I think that this part of the book is important and it is a pity the picture avoided it, as well as for some other passages. Thank you for your lovely comment. And thank you for the tag, it is greatly appreciated " | |